TOTAL LOSS APPRAISAL / State Farm / North Carolina
2016 Lexus GS F
The Valuation Issue
The insurer’s CCC ONE valuation put this low-production 2016 Lexus GS F at $47,708. It used three comparables between 265 and 427 miles away and took the same $6,267 condition deduction from every one of them, a blanket adjustment rather than a car-by-car comparison. When the insurer’s appraiser produced their own valuation, they averaged four comparables to reach $55,131. The lowest of them pulled that average down hard: a GS F listed at $39,500, roughly $20,000 below their other three, that had been on the market for more than 1,000 days. Its vehicle history showed a branded title. Two of their other comparables had spent most of their lives in New York, and one of them had a reported accident, yet their report made no adjustment for either.
Appraisal Research
We pulled the window sticker to confirm the car’s factory equipment, including the Mark Levinson audio system, and built our appraisal from four GS F comparables adjusted for mileage. Because this is an enthusiast car where history drives price, we also documented where each comparable had spent its life and whether it had an accident record, and adjusted for long-term salt-belt exposure and reported accidents. When the insurer’s appraiser’s valuation arrived, we ran vehicle-history reports on every one of their comparables and sent them the results the next day. We asked them to remove the branded-title car outright. For the two New York cars, we asked for salt-belt and accident adjustments, explaining that with a rare, collectible car, buyers place a lot of weight on accident history and long-term salt-belt exposure.
How the Case Was Resolved
The insurer’s appraiser’s valuation came in at $55,131. We answered with the vehicle-history reports and our requests: remove the branded-title comparable, and adjust the two New York cars for salt-belt exposure and accident history. The insurer’s appraiser then revised their report, added a recent auction sale of a GS F, and raised their value to $62,597, an increase of more than $7,400 over their own first number. Both appraisers agreed on $62,597, about $14,900 above the insurer’s valuation.
Questioning your insurance valuation?
Send me your valuation report. I'll review the vehicle and the market before recommending whether the appraisal clause makes sense.
Get a Free Second Opinion