TOTAL LOSS APPRAISAL / Progressive / Texas
2002 Dodge Ram 2500 5.9L Cummins Diesel 4WD
The Valuation Issue
The insurer’s valuation put this stolen 2002 Dodge Ram 2500 with the 5.9-liter Cummins diesel at about $7,950. It used only two comparable trucks, 699 and 874 miles away, both in a different cab configuration and one with nearly 300,000 miles. When the insurer’s appraiser responded to our report, their counteroffer averaged four dealer listings with a J.D. Power guidebook figure of $11,000, treated as if it were a fifth truck for sale. Three of the four listings were 2003 trucks, the first year of the next generation, each with a flat $2,000 deduction for the year difference. One of the trucks was two-wheel drive, and two came from rust-belt states.
Appraisal Research
Our appraisal used five trucks from the same generation with the same 5.9-liter Cummins and four-wheel drive, adjusted for mileage and transmission. When the insurer’s appraiser countered, we went through their comparables one by one. Their 2003 trucks were a different generation, so we answered with three Texas trucks that matched the owner’s on generation, engine and drivetrain. We pointed out that one of their comparables was two-wheel drive, and we marked up photos from the listings to show the visible corrosion on their two rust-belt trucks. When they said one of our trucks couldn’t be confirmed with the dealer, we tracked it down: it had just sold from a dealer in West Austin, and we sent them the link and the dealer’s phone number. We also pushed back on giving a guidebook figure the same weight as a real truck for sale, since guidebooks run low on these diesel trucks.
How the Case Was Resolved
The insurer’s appraiser didn’t respond to our report at first, and it took several follow-ups, including a request through the adjuster, before their counteroffer came in at $14,497. We answered with same-generation trucks and the problems in their comparables. Their reply defended the 2003 trucks as a stronger generation, but they added two of our Texas trucks and raised their value to $18,625.71. We then confirmed our third truck’s sale and sent the corrosion photos. They added that truck too, which raised their own average to $20,416.25 even with the guidebook figure still in it, and then proposed $21,088.84. Both appraisers agreed on that figure, about $13,100 above the insurer’s valuation and more than two and a half times the original figure.
Questioning your insurance valuation?
Send me your valuation report. I'll review the vehicle and the market before recommending whether the appraisal clause makes sense.
Get a Free Second Opinion