TOTAL LOSS APPRAISAL / State Farm / West Virginia
2003 Dodge Ram 2500 ST 5.9L Cummins, 5-Speed Manual
The Valuation Issue
After a garage fire, the insurer’s CCC ONE valuation put this 2003 Ram 2500 ST, with the 5.9-liter Cummins and a five-speed manual, at $9,032. The truck had about 70,000 miles. The insurer’s comparables had between 218,000 and 366,000, and the report itself treated 200,400 miles as typical for the truck. On top of that, it took an $874 condition deduction, much of it rated from photos, and a separate $2,500 deduction for “unrelated prior damage” that came with no estimate or explanation. The insurer’s appraiser carried both deductions straight into their own report. They started from a far more realistic set of low-mileage Cummins trucks, two of them the same trucks we had used in our report, then subtracted the same $874 for condition, $1,200 for cab configuration and trim, and the full $2,500 for prior damage.
Appraisal Research
Our appraisal used four Cummins trucks with comparable mileage, adjusted for trim and for transmission, since the owner’s truck had the manual. When the insurer’s appraiser’s report arrived, we went after the prior-damage deduction first and asked them what it was based on. Their answer: “It’s on the CCC report so I must add it… I don’t have the UPD estimate.” So we got it ourselves. We contacted the insurer’s adjuster, obtained the underlying damage estimate, and compared it against the truck’s pre-loss photos. The estimate called for hours of bodywork on both bedsides and the tailgate, plus both bumpers, a headlamp and a tail lamp, and the photos didn’t support it. We sent them eight of those photos. Then we went after condition. We documented the owner’s receipts for the work done on the truck, including a high-performance injection pump, an upgraded fuel system, head studs, a girdle kit, leather seating and new wheels, and showed that the report was charging the owner twice: once for condition and again for prior damage.
How the Case Was Resolved
We sent our appraisal as soon as the insurer’s appraiser was appointed, and their report followed at $25,641. We asked for the basis of the prior-damage deduction, and when they didn’t have it, we requested the estimate from the insurer ourselves. We then sent them the estimate alongside the pre-loss photos. They held their position, saying the number “is not going to change.” We came back with the owner’s receipts and the double-counting argument, and they raised their value to $27,033. We walked the owner through the choice between accepting that value and going to an umpire, including the cost and risk of each, and the owner chose to accept. Both appraisers signed the award at $27,033, about three times the insurer’s valuation.
Questioning your insurance valuation?
Send me your valuation report. I'll review the vehicle and the market before recommending whether the appraisal clause makes sense.
Get a Free Second Opinion