Skip to main content

2015 Mercedes-AMG C63 S Sedan Appraisal Clause Case Study: Allstate

← All Case Studies

TOTAL LOSS APPRAISAL / Allstate / Texas

2015 Mercedes-AMG C63 S Sedan

Original ACV $28,287
Final ACV $35,539.29
Difference +$7,252.29

The Valuation Issue

The insurer’s CCC ONE valuation put this 2015 Mercedes-AMG C63 S sedan at $28,287. It used three comparables and took the same $4,373 condition deduction from every one of them. Its equipment list credited the car with only navigation, a driver assistance package and a memory package, but the original window sticker shows about $26,000 in factory options on a car that stickered at $98,825, including carbon-ceramic brakes, AMG Performance seats, the AMG performance exhaust and exterior carbon-fiber trim. When the insurer’s appraiser produced their own position, they used dealer listings but then averaged them with a guidebook figure taken from a vehicle-history report, which pulled their number down, and adjusted for mileage at four cents a mile.

Appraisal Research

We pulled the window sticker for the owner’s car and for every comparable we used, so equipment could be compared line by line, and adjusted each comparable for its option differences from its sticker. Our appraisal used four C63 S sedans with similar mileage, adjusted for mileage and those option differences. Two of the insurer’s appraiser’s three dealer listings were the same cars we had used. When their position arrived, we challenged the guidebook blend first: the dealer market, including the cars both of us had used, supported more than the guidebook figure, and averaging the two simply pulled the value down. We then challenged their mileage rate. The major guidebooks imply a per-mile effect for this car several times larger than the four cents they used, and we asked them to support it.

How the Case Was Resolved

The insurer’s appraiser’s first position came in at $33,965.64. We answered on the guidebook blend, and they raised their value to $35,137.12. We then pressed on the mileage rate and on where the dealer listings actually pointed, and they raised their value again, to $35,539.29. Before settling, we walked the owner through the choice between accepting that value and going to an umpire, including the cost and risk of each, and the owner chose to accept. Both appraisers agreed on $35,539.29, about $7,250 (26%) above the insurer’s valuation.

Questioning your insurance valuation?

Send me your valuation report. I'll review the vehicle and the market before recommending whether the appraisal clause makes sense.

Get a Free Second Opinion