Skip to main content

2023 Honda CR-V Hybrid Sport AWD Total Loss Appraisal | Allstate

← All Case Studies

TOTAL LOSS APPRAISAL / Allstate / Pennsylvania

2023 Honda CR-V Hybrid Sport AWD

Allstate's original CCC ONE valuation placed this 2023 Honda CR-V Hybrid Sport AWD, with 76,197 miles, at $22,839.50.

Original ACV $22,839.50
Final ACV $28,448
Difference +$5,608.50

The Valuation Issue

The report used eight comparable vehicles advertised between $25,848 and $29,294. However, adjustments reduced their indicated values by approximately $3,600 to $5,800 each, resulting in adjusted values between $20,888 and $25,242.

The report also incorporated a Pennsylvania Statewide Value of $22,402. No condition deductions were applied.

The primary dispute concerned how the comparable vehicles were adjusted and how those adjusted values supported Allstate's final valuation.

Appraisal Research

I first verified the vehicle's exact configuration using its original window sticker, confirming the Sport Hybrid trim, all-wheel drive, and factory equipment.

I then identified five 2023 Honda CR-V Hybrid Sport AWD retail listings with mileage ranging from approximately 58,600 to 72,800 miles, relatively close to the subject vehicle's 76,197 miles.

Because the comparable vehicles had similar mileage, the adjustments were relatively small. Using a mileage adjustment of $0.05 per mile, each comparable required less than $900 in mileage adjustments.

The five adjusted values ranged from $28,149 to $29,658. Giving each comparable equal weight produced my appraised Actual Cash Value of $28,934.

How the Case Was Resolved

After the owner invoked the appraisal clause, Allstate appointed an independent appraiser who reviewed three comparable vehicles within 100 miles of the subject vehicle.

Using a mileage adjustment of $0.08 per mile, the opposing appraiser concluded an Actual Cash Value of $27,962, compared with my appraisal of $28,934.

With the two valuations only $972 apart, I proposed splitting the difference to avoid the additional time and expense of involving an umpire. The opposing appraiser agreed the same day.

Both appraisers agreed on a final ACV of $28,448, an increase of $5,608.50 over Allstate's original valuation of $22,839.50.

The agreement was reached approximately three weeks after the owner's initial inquiry and two weeks after Allstate appointed its appraiser.

Questioning your insurance valuation?

Send me your valuation report. I'll review the vehicle and the market before recommending whether the appraisal clause makes sense.

Get a Free Second Opinion