Skip to main content

2002 Subaru Impreza WRX Wagon Appraisal Clause Case Study: State Farm

← All Case Studies

TOTAL LOSS APPRAISAL / State Farm / Wisconsin

2002 Subaru Impreza WRX Sport Wagon

Original ACV $4,492
Final ACV $8,000
Difference +$3,508

The Valuation Issue

The insurer’s CCC ONE valuation put this 2002 Subaru Impreza WRX wagon at $4,492. It rested on just two comparables, one 445 miles away and the other 744, and the report noted that the insurer had directed which comparables and criteria to use. The car had a replacement engine documented by a $1,300 receipt, but the valuation credited it at only $458. When the insurer’s appraiser weighed in, they started from the insurer’s figure and pointed to a 2017 insurance claim in the car’s history, along with its mileage and number of owners, as reasons to hold the value down.

Appraisal Research

We assembled the documentation the insurer’s valuation had left out: the receipt for the replacement engine, the tire receipts, the owner’s photos and a comparable the owner had found, and we sent all of it to the insurer’s appraiser along with the insurer’s report. Our valuation used three comparable WRX wagons and credited the replacement engine. When the insurer’s appraiser pointed to the 2017 claim, we answered with the market data: the insurer’s own report had made no deduction for title, prior damage or condition, and two of our three comparables also had insurance losses on their records, so that kind of history was already reflected in the market value. We also kept the claim moving. When nothing had happened for weeks after the appraisal clause was invoked, we followed up and found the process had never been started on the insurer’s side; it began that day.

How the Case Was Resolved

Once the appraisal was underway, the insurer’s appraiser opened at $7,245, citing the 2017 claim. We answered with the engine credit and the comparables carrying their own loss histories. The insurer’s appraiser then raised their value to $8,000, and both appraisers agreed on that figure. That is about $3,500 (78%) above the insurer’s valuation and at the top of the range we had estimated for the owner.

Questioning your insurance valuation?

Send me your valuation report. I'll review the vehicle and the market before recommending whether the appraisal clause makes sense.

Get a Free Second Opinion