TOTAL LOSS APPRAISAL / National General / Virginia
2015 BMW 650i xDrive Gran Coupe
The Valuation Issue
The insurer valued this 2015 BMW 650i xDrive Gran Coupe at $19,166. That figure rested on nine comparables, most of them 400 to 540 miles away, each reduced by the same $1,677 condition adjustment, and two of the nine appear to be the same car listed twice. The insurer’s appraiser then built a separate valuation from a guidebook figure and three listings drawn from a radius of nearly 1,200 miles, adjusted for mileage at $0.10 a mile. Two of those three comparables had about 20,000 fewer miles than the owner’s car, and that rate took roughly $2,000 off each of them.
Appraisal Research
Our appraisal used three 2015 650i xDrive Gran Coupes in the same V8, all-wheel-drive configuration as the owner’s car, with mileage on both sides of its 76,499 miles so the adjustments stayed small. We documented the car’s factory equipment, including the M Sport, Executive and Driver Assistance packages, adaptive LED lighting and Harman Kardon audio. Our report also explained the mileage rate we used and why: market listings for this model show depreciation leveling off past roughly 50,000 miles, so a steep per-mile deduction overstates the effect of extra miles on a car like this. When the insurer’s appraiser’s valuation arrived, we showed that almost the entire difference between the two valuations came from their much steeper mileage rate.
How the Case Was Resolved
The insurer’s appraiser sent their report at $20,848, and we answered with ours, laying out where the two valuations differed. The insurer’s appraiser then raised their value to $21,300, and both appraisers agreed on that figure, about $2,100 above the insurer’s valuation.
Questioning your insurance valuation?
Send me your valuation report. I'll review the vehicle and the market before recommending whether the appraisal clause makes sense.
Get a Free Second Opinion