TOTAL LOSS APPRAISAL / Progressive / Utah
2015 Volkswagen Jetta S (Branded Title)
The Valuation Issue
This 2015 Volkswagen Jetta S had a branded title. The insurer’s Mitchell valuation priced it from six clean-title Utah dealer listings and then subtracted a generic “average” title deduction of more than $2,200, about 34% of the clean-title value, arriving at $4,361.74. The report itself said the deduction was not specific to any particular title type. When the insurer’s appraiser sent their preliminary numbers, they leaned on the same idea. Alongside two salvage-title comparables, they offered a second method: clean-title Jettas from Salt Lake City and Idaho Falls with a flat 20% taken off for the title. Their mileage adjustment came from a guidebook rather than from the market for these cars.
Appraisal Research
We valued the car the way a buyer of a branded-title car would: by what branded-title Jettas actually sell for. Our appraisal used branded-title Jettas close to the owner’s mileage, so the comparison didn’t depend on a percentage at all. When the insurer’s appraiser proposed clean-title cars less 20%, we asked them for those comparables and for the basis of both their 20% figure and their mileage rate. Their answer was that “20-30% has been a standard deduction.” Because branded-title Jettas are scarce in Utah, we kept searching the surrounding region and sent them two more branded-title listings from Colorado to go with the one we had already found in Washington, so they could see the regional market for themselves instead of relying on a percentage.
How the Case Was Resolved
The insurer’s appraiser sent their preliminary figures at $5,281.58. We sent our appraisal and challenged the clean-title-minus-a-percentage approach, asking for the support behind their deduction and their mileage rate. They defended both, but agreed that salvage-title comparables were the better measure and said they would keep looking. We then sent them the additional branded-title Jettas from Colorado. Their revised report was built entirely on branded-title vehicles: six comparables from six states, three they located and three of ours, adjusted at three cents a mile. Their value rose to $6,242.58, the average of those six branded-title comparables, and both appraisers agreed on that figure, about $1,880 (43%) above the insurer’s valuation.
Questioning your insurance valuation?
Send me your valuation report. I'll review the vehicle and the market before recommending whether the appraisal clause makes sense.
Get a Free Second Opinion