TOTAL LOSS APPRAISAL / Liberty Mutual / Pennsylvania
2018 Jaguar F-PACE 25t Premium AWD
The Valuation Issue
After this 2018 Jaguar F-PACE 25t Premium caught fire while parked, the insurer’s CCC ONE valuation put it at $11,442.50. The base value rested on just two dealer comparables: one with 148,887 miles, nearly 65,000 more than the owner’s vehicle, and one from out of state. A third listing in the report’s informational section was the same vehicle as the first, listed twice. The owner told us they had sent the insurer more than a dozen local listings, and most were left out. When the insurer’s appraiser produced their own report, it rated the vehicle and paint as Good and recorded all four tires at just 7% worn. Even so, it subtracted $1,500 as a “condition / options deduction” with no explanation. They also used a mileage adjustment of $0.10 per mile, which took nearly $3,900 off each of their two lowest-mileage comparables.
Appraisal Research
We started with the original window sticker to confirm the exact build: a 25t Premium with all-wheel drive, the 2.0-liter turbocharged engine and British Racing Green paint. We ran a vehicle-history check and built our appraisal from three F-PACE 25t Premium all-wheel-drive comparables whose mileage bracketed the owner’s vehicle, so the mileage adjustments stayed small. When the insurer’s appraiser’s report arrived, we went through it line by line and challenged two items in our first response. First, their mileage rate: we asked what market data supported $0.10 per mile, and their only answer was that it’s the rate they use “90% of the time.” Second, the $1,500 deduction: their own report described the vehicle and paint as good, so we asked for the documented condition issue or missing equipment behind it. When their next offer still didn’t address the deduction, we pressed on it again in writing.
How the Case Was Resolved
The insurer’s appraiser sent their report at $12,781, and we answered with our appraisal and our challenges. In their next response they raised their value to $13,781, defending their mileage rate but leaving the deduction unexplained. We pressed again on the $1,500, and they raised their value to $14,281. That figure is exactly the average of their own three comparables before the deduction, so the deduction we challenged came out entirely. Both appraisers agreed on $14,281, about $2,840 (25%) above the insurer’s valuation.
Questioning your insurance valuation?
Send me your valuation report. I'll review the vehicle and the market before recommending whether the appraisal clause makes sense.
Get a Free Second Opinion