Skip to main content

2019 Dodge Charger SRT Hellcat Appraisal Clause Case Study: National General

← All Case Studies

TOTAL LOSS APPRAISAL / National General / Georgia

2019 Dodge Charger SRT Hellcat

Original ACV $44,829
Final ACV $52,100
Difference +$7,271

The Valuation Issue

The insurer valued this 2019 Dodge Charger SRT Hellcat at $44,829. Hellcat prices were falling quickly in the weeks after the loss, so comparable cars listed weeks later understated what this car was worth on the date of loss. When the insurer’s appraiser produced their own report, it used four Hellcats from as far as 712 miles away and adjusted them only for mileage and prior damage: a guidebook mileage rate of twenty-four cents a mile, and a deduction for half of a $526.84 windshield estimate. Nothing in it brought the comparables back to the date of loss.

Appraisal Research

Our appraisal used four Hellcat comparables adjusted for mileage, and then went a step further. Using J.D. Power’s historical retail data for the region, we documented that values for this model had dropped about $3,500 between the date of loss and the weeks when the comparables were observed, and we reconciled the comparables back to the date of loss, with the data attached to our report. When the insurer’s appraiser’s report arrived, we challenged it on two points. First, we asked how their comparables, all listed weeks after the loss, had been brought back to the date of loss given the sharp drop in Hellcat prices. Second, we questioned their mileage rate: twenty-four cents a mile, taken from a guidebook, was far steeper than actual Hellcat listings supported.

How the Case Was Resolved

We sent our report to the insurer’s appraiser with the post-loss price drop and the data behind it called out. Their report came in at $49,076, and we answered with our questions about the date of loss and the mileage rate. In reply, the insurer’s appraiser told us they had done “some deeper digging” and raised their value to $52,100, about $3,000 above their own report. Both appraisers agreed on $52,100, about $7,300 (16%) above the insurer’s valuation.

Questioning your insurance valuation?

Send me your valuation report. I'll review the vehicle and the market before recommending whether the appraisal clause makes sense.

Get a Free Second Opinion