Skip to main content

2017 Ford Explorer XLT EcoBoost Appraisal Clause Case Study: Progressive

← All Case Studies

TOTAL LOSS APPRAISAL / Progressive / Ohio

2017 Ford Explorer XLT 2.3L EcoBoost AWD

Original ACV $13,313.49
Final ACV $15,800
Difference +$2,486.51

The Valuation Issue

The insurer’s valuation put this 2017 Ford Explorer XLT at $13,313.49. The vehicle had the 2.3-liter EcoBoost engine, all-wheel drive, Equipment Group 201A and the XLT Technology package, so the comparables had to match a specific build. The insurer’s appraiser’s first report used three comparables that didn’t. When we pulled their window stickers, every one turned out to be a lower Equipment Group 200A vehicle without the XLT Technology package, with the 3.5-liter V6 instead of the EcoBoost, and an original MSRP $3,500 to $4,100 below the owner’s Explorer. Their report also limited the search to 100 miles of the owner’s ZIP code, which left few true matches, and factored in prior body scratches and a market-timing adjustment.

Appraisal Research

We pulled the original window sticker for the owner’s Explorer and for every comparable the insurer’s appraiser used, so equipment could be compared line by line rather than by trim name. Our own appraisal used four EcoBoost all-wheel-drive XLTs adjusted for mileage. Each time the insurer’s appraiser revised their report, we checked the new comparables the same way. When they replaced their V6 comparables with Equipment Group 202A vehicles, we showed that the new set had much higher mileage and that one of them was front-wheel drive, not all-wheel drive. When they said they wouldn’t consider vehicles beyond their search radius, we found more EcoBoost all-wheel-drive Explorers inside it, pulled window stickers for those as well, and sent them to the insurer’s appraiser. We answered every objection with documented vehicles that met their own rules: the same engine, the same drivetrain, comparable equipment, and inside their chosen search area.

How the Case Was Resolved

The insurer’s appraiser revised their report three times as we answered each version. Their first report came in at $15,000. We sent window stickers showing their comparables didn’t match the owner’s Explorer, and they issued a second report with new comparables at $15,300. We pointed out the mileage gap and the front-wheel-drive comparable and supplied EcoBoost all-wheel-drive matches; their third report added mileage adjustments, corrected the drivetrain and rose to $15,650. When we sent two more comparables inside their radius, with window stickers, their fourth report added them and came to $15,800. Both appraisers agreed on $15,800, about $2,500 (19%) above the insurer’s valuation.

Questioning your insurance valuation?

Send me your valuation report. I'll review the vehicle and the market before recommending whether the appraisal clause makes sense.

Get a Free Second Opinion