TOTAL LOSS APPRAISAL / Progressive / Arizona
2020 Jeep Wrangler Unlimited Sport S 4WD (Branded Title)
The Valuation Issue
This 2020 Jeep Wrangler Unlimited Sport S had a branded title from a prior salvage. The insurer’s Mitchell valuation priced it from eight clean-title comparables and then subtracted a generic “average” title deduction of more than $8,100, about 37%, arriving at $14,190.60. The report itself described that deduction as not specific to any particular title type. The insurer’s appraiser took the same approach. They built their value from four clean-title Wranglers and applied a flat percentage for the salvage history: 30% in their email to us, and 35% in their written report. Their closest comparable, just 15 miles away, wasn’t even the same vehicle. It had the 3.6-liter V6, while the owner’s Jeep had the 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder with the eight-speed automatic.
Appraisal Research
Rather than apply a percentage, we went looking for the real market: Wranglers with branded titles in the same Sport S configuration, with the 2.0-liter turbo, eight-speed automatic and four-wheel drive. We confirmed the owner’s options from the original window sticker. Branded-title Wranglers were scarce near the owner, so we searched further, and we sent our report to the insurer’s appraiser before they wrote their own so the comparison started from real branded-title data. When their numbers arrived, we challenged both their method and their comparables. We asked why they would take a flat percentage off clean-title vehicles when actual branded-title vehicles were on the market, and we pointed out that their closest comparable had the wrong engine. When they said they didn’t like comparing salvage-title vehicles “when I don’t have all the facts,” we kept supplying more branded-title Wranglers, including one we found while preparing our submission to the umpire. We also gave the owner a template to request the undisputed portion of the claim from the insurer while the appraisal continued.
How the Case Was Resolved
We sent our appraisal as soon as the insurer’s appraiser was appointed. In reply, they told us they didn’t see themselves “coming anywhere close” to our figure and put their value at $15,494.60. We answered on their method and their V6 comparable, then sent them another branded-title Wrangler. They replied that our number was “not going to happen on my side,” and then raised their value to $16,500. With the appraisers still apart, we laid out the options for the owner: accept, or ask an umpire to decide, knowing an umpire could raise, keep or lower the value. The owner chose the umpire.
An umpire was then agreed on. We sent the umpire our full report and two more branded-title Wranglers, one of them found while we were preparing the submission, with a written submission explaining that the core disagreement was comparable selection: actual branded-title market data is a better indicator than clean-title vehicles with a subjective percentage deduction. We kept the owner updated while the umpire reviewed both appraisers’ reports, the photos and the documentation, and confirmed the details with both appraisers. The umpire set the value at $17,735. That is about $3,500 above the insurer’s valuation and $1,235 above the insurer’s appraiser’s highest offer, and it works out to roughly a 20% reduction from the insurer’s own clean-title figure, compared with the 30% to 37% the insurer and its appraiser had applied.
Questioning your insurance valuation?
Send me your valuation report. I'll review the vehicle and the market before recommending whether the appraisal clause makes sense.
Get a Free Second Opinion