Skip to main content

Total Loss Offer Too Low?
Find Out for Free.

ASCAA Certified  ·  Serving Clients Nationwide  ·  Money-Back Guarantee if we can’t increase the ACV by at least $1,000

Request Your Free Review

Takes about 2 minutes. If you have a valuation report from the insurance company, please attach it.


No obligation. No fees unless you hire us.
If your offer is actually fair, I’ll tell you that too.

Privacy Policy

Most people have never dealt with a total loss before. Then one day your car is totaled, the insurance company sends you an offer that doesn’t come close to what it would actually cost to replace it.

So you start researching. You find out the offer is based on a CCC One or Mitchell “valuation report” you never agreed to. You learn there’s something called the appraisal clause in your policy. But you’re wondering if it’s worth fighting, or if maybe the number is actually fair.

I get it. I started Fair Auto Appraisals after my truck caught fire on the interstate heading to a camping trip in Utah. Then I spent months fighting my insurer over the value. I know exactly what it feels like to stare at a lowball offer and have no idea what to do next.

Since then I’ve handled hundreds of these disputes. I’m ASCAA certified, and I know the specific errors CCC makes. Wrong trim levels. Comps that don’t actually exist. Condition adjustments with zero explanation. Pulling vehicles from salt belt states to drag your value down. I see it all the time.

Fill out the form and I’ll review your vehicle, your offer, and the valuation report from the insurance company if you have one. If you’re being underpaid, I’ll tell you by how much and what your options are. If the offer is actually fair, I’ll tell you that too. I’m not here to sell you something you don’t need. And if you do decide to hire us, our fees are straightforward. You can see them here.

Recent Wins

+$4,2752010 Cadillac CTS · State Farm

+$4,7352017 Ford F-350 · Progressive

+$1,5072010 Toyota Prius · Geico

+$4,5462015 Chrysler 200 · National General

$30,0642001 Dodge Ram 2500 · Geico · Offer was $4,404

+$3,8922001 Chevrolet Silverado 3500 · Farmers

+$4,8862024 Toyota Grand Highlander Hybrid · LM General

+$1,6362021 Ford Transit Cargo Van · Erie

+$10,5582006 Acura RSX · Progressive · Offer was $7,442

+$6,6242006 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 · USAA

+$3,4552017 Subaru Legacy · Root

+$5,7912019 Ford Mustang · Resolved in 6 days

+$5,2962016 GMC Sierra 1500 · State Farm · Resolved in 10 days

+$15,4202018 Cadillac CTS-V · USAA · CCC full of errors